Did You Really Choose Your Musical Preferences? 

Did You Really Choose Your Musical Preferences?

 

The hidden guides of Circumstance and Temperament.

 

 

When I was a kid, my favourite band was The Beach Boys. This was up until around 1989. But then within a year or two, my favourite band was Pestilence. As you can probably guess from the name, Pestilence are a death metal band. They’re still going actually, and they’re still one of my favourite bands! But let’s explore that transition from The Beach Boys to Pestilence, because that’s quite the paradigm shift.

 

I haven’t spent much time thinking about this drastic change of musical preference until recently. For the last couple months I’ve been reading Dr. Alice Miller’s life-changing books and working through a lot of childhood stuff. I realised that there were significant changes to my circumstances in this two-year period, which in-turn significantly changed my worldview. And apparently, this significant change in worldview resulted in a significant change in musical preference, too.

 

Then this morning I was reading Mark Twain’s utterly brilliant and thought-provoking essay The Turning-Point of My Life. He builds a convincing case for determinism, showing that the only reason he became a writer was because he got the measles when he was 12 years old. Interestingly, that was around the age of my paradigm shift mentioned above. So from his measles experience, Twain maps the chain of events that eventually led him to writing his first book, 20 years later!

 

Subscribe to get the latest posts in your inbox.

 

He shows how two factors guide our lives: circumstance and temperament. If we look back on our lives, we can clearly see how they’ve been guiding us all along. With regards to circumstance, for example, we can’t choose where we’re born. This determines the language we speak and the cultural air we breathe. And with regards to temperament. When different people experience the same situation, they react and behave in very different ways depending on their individual nature.

 

This dual guidance includes our preference for musical genres and artists, and even specific songs, too. Think about it. When you hear a new song, do you reasonably consider whether you like it or not, or do you just viscerally react? And if we’re honest, that’s true for all our preferences. Think about food. Why does one person love Brussels sprouts, and another hates them? It was never a conscious choice they made, the decision was made a long time ago by circumstance and temperament.

 

So the next time you hear someone blasting music you hate, take a moment to accept that if you had their life circumstances and temperament, you’d also love that music. And this can be applied to absolutely everything.

 

Subscribe to get the latest posts in your inbox.

 

Think about sports teams. I’m not a team-sports guy myself, but here in Canada they’re all about hockey. And we’re currently living in the Calgary area of Alberta, so the hockey team here is the Flames. But if you drive three hours up the highway to Edmonton, their team is the Oilers. Both cities have a similar population size, and both teams are exceptional, so as you can imagine, the rivalry is intense!

 

But why does someone become a Flames fan instead of an Oilers fan? Yep, because they were born in Calgary. Or perhaps their father’s from Calgary and they grew up watching games together on TV. The reality is obvious, though. However someone ends up a Calgary Flames fan, or a fan of any other team in any other sport, it was chosen for them by circumstance and temperament.

 

And this goes for politics, too. You know that neighbour over the road that votes for the other party? Well, if we had their life circumstances and temperament, we’d also vote for that party. Okay now quickly bringing things back to music, because three sentences on politics is already three too many.

 

Subscribe to get the latest posts in your inbox.

 

Some musical preferences are also connected to where people were born. For example, Kate was born and raised here in Calgary, so she grew up listening to country music. And if you’re not familiar with the city also known as Cowtown, it’s world-famous for the Calgary Stampede, which is a rodeo and festival of colossal proportions! So it’s common for people born here to like country music, whereas I didn’t know anyone in South Africa, where I grew up, who liked country music.

 

A quick, fun side-note. While I’m still not a fan of country music in general, I have actually found a few country artists I really enjoy! My two favourites are Colter Wall from up here in Canada, and Cody Jinks down in America. They’re awesome!

 

So when I was pondering how I could integrate Mark Twain’s insights into my daily life, I thought of a new kindness practice that I’m now working on. Every time I hear music that I don’t like, I’m taking a moment to accept that if I had that person’s life circumstances and temperament, I’d like that music too. If we all take a moment to do this every time we hear music we don’t like, I think we can make the world a little bit kinder. And who doesn’t want to live in a kinder world, right?

 

 

 

Lastly, if you’re interested in making music yourself, you can download my Free Book and Free PDF Tutorials. I’ve got resources for songwriters and producers at every level, from complete beginner all the way up to advanced. And if you’d like me to keep doing this work, you can become a paid subscriber on my Substack.

 

A heartfelt thank-you to all the kind people currently paying. There are 28 of you at the moment. I know each one of you by name. I see you, and I thank you for sticking with me through this difficult time. It means the world to me. And please know that I’m working really hard on overcoming my depression and anxiety, so I can post more regularly once again.

 

If you can’t afford to become a paid subscriber or make a one-off contribution right now, though, no problem, you can give the podcast a 5-star rating in your app, and share this episode with someone who may find it interesting. That helps support my work, too. Thanks for being here, I truly appreciate you. I’m Ray Harmony, and I hope you’ll join me again next time. Until then, remember to stop and smell the music.

 

Photo by Mart Production

 

 


 

About.

 

Ray Harmony is a multi award-winning music lecturer who’s made music with Serj Tankian (System Of A Down), Tom Morello (Rage Against The Machine), Steven Wilson (Porcupine Tree), Devin Townsend (Strapping Young Lad), Ihsahn (Emperor), Kool Keith (Ultramagnetic MCs), Madchild (Swollen Members), and more. Ray is also the founder of Hack Music Theory, a YouTube channel with over 10 million views and over 255,000 subscribers learning the fast, easy and fun way to make music without using AI, cos it ain’t no fun getting a robot to write “your” songs! Everything here is 100% Human and 0% AI.

 

 

Photo by kaboompics.com

 

 

 

Outro music by Ray Harmony, based on the music theory from GoGo Penguin "Everything Is Going to Be OK".

 

 


 

Podcast.

Listen below, or on any podcast app.